Audit Scotland
Most patients are satisfied with NHS out-of-hours care. But fewer GPs are working during the out-of-hours
period and there is a significant risk the service is unsustainable in its current form.
An Audit Scotland report published today, Primary care out-of-hours services, looks at how out-of-hours care has been
managed and delivered since responsibility for it shifted from GPs to NHS boards in 2004. Since then, 95 per cent of
Scotland’s GP practices have opted out of providing 24-hour care to their patients.
Under the new system of out-of-hours care, GP practices can opt out of providing out-of-hours care but GPs can then
choose to deliver some out-of-hours work to NHS boards for a fee. But the number of doctors doing this work is
steadily dropping, particularly in rural areas. The report says NHS boards and the Scottish Executive need to invest in
extending the roles of other health professionals, such as nurses and paramedics, and in developing new models for
delivering the service.
Deputy Auditor General for Scotland Caroline Gardner said: “Since the changes to out-of-hours services three years
ago, NHS boards have worked hard to maintain the care patients have traditionally experienced, and most patients are
satisfied. However the way the service is currently delivered needs to change as there is a significant risk that it is
unsustainable in its current form, particularly in Scotland’s rural and remote areas.
“The Scottish Executive should look to healthcare professionals other than GPs and consider how to extend their roles
and skills. Meanwhile NHS boards should continue to develop how they work with partners, such as NHS 24 and the
ambulance service, to deliver out-of-hours care for patients.”
Boards covering Scotland’s rural and remote areas are under the most pressures in providing out-of-hours. Since the
changes to the service there have been reductions in GPs choosing to work out-of-hours and costs in remote and rural
areas are higher. In 2005/06 providing out-of-hours care in the Argyll and Bute area cost six times that of doing so in
Greater Glasgow (£43.63 per person compared with £7.61).
The report also finds that there is a lack of monitoring of changes to out-of-hours services, so it is difficult to assess the
impact on patients. However as part of the report Audit Scotland carried out a survey that found that more than 80 per
cent of patients who have accessed out-of-hours care are satisfied with the service they received.